'Have to ask questions of everybody' – Graeme Smith

Former South African captain Graeme Smith has shifted the spotlight off the field and onto the management in the aftermath of South Africa’s second successive series defeat. Speaking on television channel Smith explained the responsibility for the recent performances should be shared by several senior personnel, including the coaches.”The players have to take responsibility for their performances, there’s no doubt about that, but the management do too. They haven’t quite come into the equation of late. At the end the day the performances of the Test team for the last year haven’t been good enough, so you have to ask questions of everybody,” Smith said.”How is management getting the best out of them, how are they preparing them, are they directed in the right way, do they need to be firmer, do they need to be softer? I don’t know.”Smith spent a session before the New Year’s Test in the nets with South Africa’s batsmen and was said to be in talks to take on a consulting role for the remainder of the series. But he was also contracted as a commentator for and and those prior commitments were in conflict with a coaching stint which has confined him to being behind the microphone and not in the dressing room which has left South Africa without a batting coach.Since Russell Domingo took over the coaching job in June 2013, he has made use of three former internationals to assist in the batting department. Gary Kirsten, Domingo’s predecessor, had a 50-days-a-year deal with South Africa through 2014 and Mike Hussey was on the support staff during the 2015 World Cup and briefly before the first Test on the tour to India in November. South Africa did not have any other batting experts with the squad for the rest of the India series, which they lost 3-0, or before the England matches.In India, they managed a highest innings total of 214, were shot out for their lowest score since readmission when they were bowled out for 79 in Nagpur and did not boast a single century-stand. When Smith criticised them on air, he was called in to help.His short time with the team did not have too much of an impact on their fortunes. Although South Africa showed more fight at Newlands, racking up 627 for 7 to put pressure back on England, they struggled at the Wanderers where they were dismissed for a paltry 83, their lowest at home. They have gone 12 months without a Test victory since beating West Indies in January 2014 and have conceded the No.1 ranking.With several issues raging in the background – the push towards aggressive transformation, a mid-series change of captain and injuries to key members of the pace pack – the squad appears to be struggling to keep morale up and Smith has sensed that.”Some of the decision-making around the space looks a bit worrisome for me. The team seems a bit flat. Some of the messages coming out in the press conferences don’t seem positive and it’s coming from senior players,” he said. “You’re in a big series and there is a lot of negativity among your senior players. It looks like someone needs to grab the bull by the horns and say, ‘listen guys, let’s wake up and let’s pull our finger out and let’s go and play some Test cricket’.”AB de Villiers has been of particular concern, especially for his pre-match comments ahead of the Wanderers Test, his first as captain. He did not deny reports suggesting he was considering early retirement and admitted he was “searching for answers,” on how to manage his workload. After the Test, he offered some reassurance by committing himself to Test cricket but the mood was still sombre. “I almost feel like all hope is gone,” de Villiers said.That kind of talk is what Smith is urging South Africa to avoid while still encouraging them to pay attention to what is being said in the public domain about their performances. “These are all questions that need to come out of the environment. When you are not performing well, people are going to ask questions and you’ve got to live with it,” he said.Smith is not the only former player to express this opinion. Mark Boucher posted a message on Twitter saying South Africa should go “back to the drawing board,” while Daryll Cullinan encouraged them to embrace, rather than ignore the chorus or criticism coming their way.”There is nothing wrong with criticism as long as it is backed up by facts and has credibility behind it,” Cullian wrote on Facebook. “One of the things that our cricket lacks is the maturity to embrace it, work with it and evaluate its value. This can only come from people who are secure enough in the own opinions and credibility. When they are not, they surround themselves with like-minded people, have a laager [siege] mentality, label the critics as negative who have nothing good to say and only out to breakdown our game.”

Peshawar survive Bopara onslaught for three-run win

Scorecard and ball-by-ball detailsMohammad Hafeez struck a rapid fifty to take Peshawar Zalmi to 182•PCB

West Indies’ Twenty20 captain Darren Sammy held his nerve with the ball, conceding just nine runs off the final over to guide his team Peshawar Zalmi to a thrilling three-run victory against Karachi Kings in Sharjah.After 39 overs of a contest that swung one way and then another, the equation was that Karachi needed 13 runs off six balls; Peshawar needed three wickets to secure the win and go top of the table. Sammy bowled full and wide first ball, and Ravi Bopara, who had almost single-handedly brought Karachi back into the game, whacked a six over the cover-point boundary. Bopara then helped himself to a two next ball. Five needed off four balls, with Karachi holding the edge.Bopara could have sealed a famous win off the next ball, but sent Sammy’s full toss straight down the throat of long on. Peshawar were lifted, and Usama Mir could only manage a single off the fourth delivery. Karachi knew they had to run for anything, and their sneaky attempt at stealing a bye off the fifth ball was unsuccessful, as Mir was run out. That left Mohammad Amir, the new man in, with the unenviable task of hitting four off the last ball. After a huge discussion between Sammy and his captain Shahid Afridi, Sammy ran in to bowl the final ball from around the wicket. His wide yorker was not accurate, but Amir failed to get any bat on it, and the Peshawar players broke into wild celebrations.A close finish was the last thing on everyone’s mind, especially Peshawar’s, when they reduced Karachi to 48 for 5 in a tough chase of 183. However, Bopara inspired a turnaround, blasting five fours and four sixes during a 33-ball 67 which threatened to take the game away from Peshawar. Bopara put up fifty-plus stands with James Vince and Sohail Tanvir, but unfortunately for Karachi, fell right when his team needed him the most.Earlier, Mohammad Hafeez blasted his first fifty of the season to power Peshawar to 182 for 4. Peshawar, opting to bat, began on the front foot, as Hafeez and Tamim Iqbal put up an opening stand of 93, before late blitzes from Sammy and Afridi lifted the team past the 180-run mark. Hafeez slammed seven fours and three sixes during his 59.

England resume winning ways

England 183 for 9 (Taylor 62) beat New Zealand A 86 (Guha 3-9) by 97 runs
ScorecardEngland’s women got the New Zealand-leg of their tour off to a winning start with a 97-run victory over New Zealand A in Lincoln.Acting captain Claire Taylor’s 62 was the basis of the side’s 183 for 9, with a third-wicket stand of 107 with Jenny Gunn (47) providing the bulk of the runs. But there were alarms as they slid from 122 for 2 to 131 for 7, and it took cameos from Caroline Atkins (23*) and Stephanie Davies (25) to give the score respectability.New Zealand A were never in the race as they were skittled for 86. Even that represented a recovery as at one stage they were 36 for 7. Isa Guha grabbed 3 for 9 while Gunn and Charlotte Russell picked up two wickets each.”I’m really happy with the professional performance from the team,” Taylor said. “There are still areas for improvement with both bat and ball … losing five wickets for nine runs in the middle order and bowling too many wides.”

Lorgat capable of ICC juggling act

Haroon Lorgat has balanced politics and cricketing necessities, a telling quality for a future ICC chief executive © Getty Images
 

Haroon Lorgat, 47, comes to the ICC with his most telling qualification being that he somehow managed to maintain some degree of selectorial integrity while operating within the confines and bizarreness of South African cricket’s politically-directed affirmative action policies. Lorgat headed South Africa’s selection panel from 2004 to 2007 when the team did not have the services of the maturing bunch of stars they do now, but their record was still impressive.Lorgat brought stability to selection after the often puzzling reign of Omar Henry, but it was a pity Lorgat and Graeme Smith could never quite hit it off. Their relationship was littered with arguments over whether players should be chosen when not 100% fit, and it all came to a messy head in Cape Town in November 2006 when TV cameras caught their argument at the toss in full and embarrassing technicolour.But Lorgat’s tenure showed that he could juggle both politics and cricketing necessities and that is surely a telling quality when it comes to heading up the ICC. Players called him a ‘liar’, administrators said he was ‘right’, and fans didn’t know what to make of him, which is about as good as you can hope for when your brief is, basically, ‘pick this team but tell them it’s for this reason, them that it’s for the other reason, and the others that it’s none of their business.’But his time as convenor of selectors represents only a small part of his involvement in cricket. Lorgat served on the 2003 World Cup organising committee and was also treasurer of Cricket South Africa, an obvious appointment given his background. He completed his accounting articles with Coopers & Lybrand, before going it alone for eight years. He joined Ernst & Young as a senior partner in 2002 and last year set up Kapela Investments with five other associates.The CSA chief executive, Gerald Majola, goes back a long way with Lorgat: “We made our debut together for Eastern Province. I was dropped straight away because I scored nought and one, but Haroon scored 49.”We played together from childhood, our first tournament together was the Under-19s in Cape Town in 1975. He was a stylish batsman and a good bowler too, more in the Polly mould in that he was containing and would always bowl a good line and length. He was a top-order batsman and medium-pace bowler, one of our best allrounders in fact.”Majola’s backing was similarly effusive for Lorgat’s position as the ICC’s chief executive. “I have no doubt he will make a success of the ICC job, he has very good business acumen and he was Cricket South Africa’s treasurer for a while. He will do a good job because he understands the game and is passionate about it.”Lorgat’s heritage, a South African of Indian descent, is another reason why the ICC seem in a rush to pick him as their new CEO. A thoughtful, level-headed man, Lorgat will be expected to bridge the divide between East and West in cricket’s corridors of power.Currently based in Cape Town, Lorgat was a left-hand batsman and a right-arm seamer who scored 2813 runs and took 191 wickets in 76 first-class matches. He is married with a son and a daughter.

Sobuj, Abrar help Bangladesh seal comprehensive win over Nepal

Md Sobuj’s three-for crushed Nepal’s middle order, before an unbeaten 70 from Bangladesh opener Zawad Abrar sealed their seven-wicket thumping, with 151 balls to spare. It took Bangladesh to the top of Group B with a healthy net run rate of 1.56.After being put into bat, Nepal got off to a good start, thanks to a 40-run opening stand between Sahil Patel and Niraj Kumar Yadav. Opening bowler Saad Islam made the initial breakthrough, getting Patel for 18. Sobuj then took over with with three wickets in quick succession.First to fall was Niraj – caught behind – while Nischal Kshetri was bowled for a golden duck. Cibrin Shrestha was out caught and bowled as Nepal slipped from 60 for 2 to 61 for 5.Aashish Luhar’s handy 23 and Abhisekh Tiwari’s 30 carried Nepal forward, but a second flurry of wickets ensured the rebuilding effort did not last for long. After a 38-run seventh wicket stand between Tiwari and Luhar, Azizul Hakim and Shahriar Ahmed made short work of the tail – Nepal went from 119 for 6 to 130 all out.The only downside for Bangladesh was the 17 wides they conceded, which formed an extras tally of 23.Abrar was the rock of the chase with his 68-ball 70*, including seven fours and three sixes. The only moments of concern in the innings came in the fourth over, when opener Rifat Beg was bowled for 5, followed by captain Azizul Hakim being run out the very next ball for 1.Abrar and Kalam Siddiki added 92 for 115 balls for the third wicket. By the time Siddiki fell, Bangladesh were ten runs away from victory. Rizan Hossan finished the game with a six.

How ponders what might have been

Jamie How reached his highest Test score but admitted: ‘I’ll be replaying that last over for quite a while’ © Getty Images
 

Jamie How couldn’t hide his disappointment at the close of play after falling eight runs short of a maiden Test century, but he took solace in the fact that his efforts had given New Zealand a fighting chance of a competitive total in the first Test against England at Hamilton.”It’s in the balance still,” said How, after New Zealand reached the close handily placed on 282 for 6. “We lost a couple more wickets than we’d have liked, but there were a few itchy moments out there. The England bowlers bowled well all day and it was a hard slog as shown by the run-rate. It would have been nice to cap it off, but tomorrow morning, in the first hour, it’s a big part of the game.”How burst into the limelight during New Zealand’s one-day series win, where he scored a remarkable century in the tied ODI at Napier, but his failure to emulate that effort today cleared grated. After going to the tea break on 90 not out, he survived just eight more deliveries as Monty Panesar turned one past his defences and into the hands of Paul Collingwood at slip.”You keep reminding yourself that if someone gave you 90 at the start of the day you’d be happy,” said How, “but it still hurts and I’ll be replaying that last over for quite a while. But hopefully not for too long.”Nevertheless, his innings was a distinct improvement on his previous efforts in Test cricket, in which he had managed a top score of 37 in six matches. “It’s been a bit frustrating,” he said. “I haven’t played well in Test cricket in my first few games and you see the stats come up and it’s a bit embarrassing to be honest. I’ll be working hard to put it right. I’m not a big stats person but it’s nice to get that highest score.”Despite his downbeat demeanour, How clearly felt that his international career had turned a corner following his success in the one-dayers. “It gave me confidence and form,” he said. “I like to give myself time, even in the one-dayers, so it was nice to dig in and let them come to you and bat for as long as you can today. I set myself up to bat late into that last session, but unfortunately it wasn’t to be.”New Zealand’s hopes of a big score now rest on the shoulders of Ross Taylor, who also produced his best score to date in Test cricket. Belying his one-day reputation as a big-hitter, he knuckled down for an unbeaten 54 from 121 balls, and How was impressed with his application.”It’s a work in progress, but I’ve not seen him that disciplined or that straight,” he said. “He stuck at it, and in such an unfamiliar way because he’s such an aggressive player. But he tempered that well.”

Canterbury facing gloomy battle to avoid defeat

Canterbury’s Shell Trophy fixture with Central Districts moved gloomilytowards a conclusion at Village Green today.Play was delayed until 4.45pm by heavy overnight rain. The groundsmen had towork hard to get the pitch ready when the rain stopped at 2.00pm.Any hopes of a brighter Cantabrian dawn were dashed by suicidal batting asthe home team’s spirits fell as quickly as the afternoon clouds had risen.They eventually closed on 63/3.Martyn Sigley had previously breezily smashed Chris Martin all round theground to add 29 of the 30 CD runs scored in just 20 minutes after theresumption.Carl Anderson and Stephen Cunis removed the tailenders, but Canterbury werefaced with scoring 246 to make the Stags bat again.Harley James and Jarrod Englefield both went in dull fashion. James droveairily at Gareth West and was caught by Mark Douglas at slip for two.Englefield completed a miserable match by getting run out after being sentback by Robbie Frew.Garry MacDonald, Canterbury’s coach, had a darker and darker demeanour ashis side failed to weather the CD storm. If it wasn’t for three missedchances in the slips before the score had reached 30, Cantabrian tearsmight have flooded the carefully mopped ground.Golden-arm Oram then struck a lightning bolt through Canterbury’s thunderstorm. Stead flashed a cut, and Oram had struck, with Mathew Sinclair takingthe catch at gully.Little rays of sunshine from Michael Papps, fresh from three ducks in a row,batted Canterbury through to the close with Frew. The Darfield-borndraughtsman was also missed when he gloved a hook off Oram. A big lbw shoutfrom the same bowler was a close shave too for Frew, who ended 23 not out.As the light failed Canterbury paddled away across the damp outfield toclose at a dismal 63/3.MacDonald spoke exclusively to CricInfo today at a rainy Village Green inChristchurch, citing staleness as his reason to move on. “I’ve had fouryears now and it’s probably time to do something else. I think it’s good forthe players, after the amount of time I’ve been with them, to have someoneelse. It freshens them and I got to make sure I don’t get stale myself.”Canterbury have won just one competitive game in 10 during 2000/01. Theylie bottom of both the Shell Trophy and Shell Cup.The failure of Canterbury’s young players to “kick on” has been as much as adisappointment as Canterbury’s Black Caps refusal to play domestic cricket.This was highlighted by Mathew Sinclair and Jacob Oram’s appearances forCentral Districts, while Nathan Astle and Craig McMillan pronouncedthemselves unavailable for the ongoing bottom of the table Trophy clash.Canterbury’s second-string top order collapsed to eight for five in thislatest Trophy game, with MacDonald, a former Canterbury player, commenting”we keep losing clumps of wickets. We’ve been losing four at a time, instrong positions as well, which has been putting us on the back foot.””We’ve been off the pace in both competitions. In the Cup our bowling hasbeen very inconsistent. Our batting has been, well, usually we’ve got enoughruns for a Canterbury team to defend. Our fielding and catching has beenaverage. That’s got to go up and the bowling’s got to be tighter.”The positives this season have been few. Promising performances against theZimbabwe tourists now mean little, with the lack of success in domesticcricket the benchmark MacDonald is judged on.Canterbury won the Shell Cup twice in three seasons under MacDonald, buthave finished bottom in the Shell Trophy in each of the last two years,having won it in 1997/98.While MacDonald is hoping to do some specialist spin bowling coaching- “I’ma bit young to retire yet”- there is no word on a successor, whose big hopemust be to have a full complement of internationals at his disposal.Michael Sharpe, successful coach of Canterbury second XI, is a possibilityas a replacement, having served the same apprenticeship as MacDonald and hispredecessor, Dennis Aberhart.Ben Harris, Canterbury selector and brother of Chris, from the localcandidates, has had his name mentioned in connection with the soon to bevacant post too.The seconds won the National Provincial competition under Canterbury Countrymainstay and Canterbury selector, Sharpe. The Rangiora-born formerprovincial seamer was a member of the successful Canterbury team of thenineties. Whether he would take the role, with so much knowledge of itschallenges as well as its high points remains to be seen.

Sri Lanka get a shot at history

A win in Port-of-Spain will make Sri Lanka the first visitors to clean-sweep the West Indies © Getty Images
 

Match facts

Thursday, April 3, 2008
Start time 1000 (local) 1400 (GMT)

The big picture

A victory in the opening Test in Guyana has given Sri Lanka a golden opportunity to claim their first series win in the Caribbean. A win here would also give them a special record: they will become the first visiting side to complete a clean-sweep in the West Indies. Australia came close five years ago, when they won the first three Tests but a record-breaking chase in the final Test in Antigua snuffed out their hopes of a whitewash.Sri Lanka pulled off a 121-run win in the opening Test in Guyana, with Chaminda Vaas engineering the triumph with a splendid 8 for 109. It was their first Test win in five attempts, giving them a shot at an unprecedented sweep.The fact that a scheduled warm-up game was cancelled, owing to logistical reasons, is unlikely to dampen Sri Lankan spirits. Mahela Jayawardene has urged his side to go for a win while Chris Gayle, his counterpart, has plenty of problems with regard to team selection. It will no doubt be an uphill task but West Indies have a record to defend and plenty of pride to play for. The weather, though, might have the final say.

Form Guide – West Indies

Last five completed matches: LWLLLPlayer to watch: Amit Jaggernauth’s exclusion from the side for the first Test created a lot of controversy but he’s likely to win his Test cap in front of his home crowd. Jaggernauth’s chances were vastly improved with his match-winning performance in the final round Carib Beer Series match against Barbados last weekend. He is the highest wicket-taker in the tournament with 40 wickets at 14.40.

Last five completed matches: WWWDWPlayer to watch: Thilan Thushara offered steady support to the experienced bowling duo of Chaminda Vaas and Muttiah Muralitharan with match figures of 5 for 129 runs from 37.5 overs. One among the long line of left-arm seamers to have played for Sri Lanka, Thushara made his Test debut on Sri Lanka’s previous trip to the Caribbean five years ago. He subsequently faded but grabbed the opportunity in the first Test to stake his claim for a longer tenure.

Team news

West Indies will be without allrounder Ryan Hinds, who has a hamstring strain. It means Sewnarine Chattergoon, now fully recovered from the illness, is set to make his Test debut ahead of Devon Smith. He is likely to open along with Chris Gayle. There could also be a rare sight of two specialist spinners in the West Indian squad with Jaggernauth in line to join left-arm spinner Sulieman Benn in the side. The other option was to pick Fidel Edwards as a third fast bowler to support Daren Powell and Jerome Taylor.Sri Lanka were sweating over the fitness of Prasanna Jayawardene, who missed the final stages of the Guyana Test because of a hamstring injury, but he is set to retain his spot. Ishara Amarasinghe remains an option, instead of Rangana Herath, but it’s difficult to see Sri Lanka making too many changes to the winning side.West Indies (probable XI) 1 Chris Gayle (capt), 2 Sewnarine Chattergoon, 3 Ramnaresh Sarwan, 4 Marlon Samuels, 5 Shivnarine Chanderpaul, 6 Dwayne Bravo, 7 Denesh Ramdin (wk), 8 Daren Powell, 9 Jerome Taylor, 10 Sulieman Benn, 11 Amit Jaggernauth.Sri Lanka (probable XI) 1 Michael Vandort, 2 Malinda Warnapura, 3 Kumar Sangakkara, 4 Mahela Jayawardene (capt), 5 Thilan Samaraweera, 6 Tillakaratne Dilshan, 7 Prasanna Jayawardene (wk), 8 Chaminda Vaas, 9 Thilan Thushara, 10 Rangana Herath, 11 Muttiah Muralitharan.Umpires: Simon Taufel, Billy Bowden.

Pitch & conditions

Rain could play a part in the way the pitch behaves. Brian Davis, the groundsman, has spoken about a seamer-friendly track but things could be way different if West Indies choose two spinners. “Surely nobody wants all pitches to be built just for batsmen,” he said.Weather: The forecast isn’t too rosy with showers expected on the second, third and fifth days. The opening day could be overcast too.

Stats

  • If Sri Lanka win this Test, they would be the first visiting team to complete a clean-sweep in the Caribbean.
  • Shivnarine Chanderpaul is yet to score a hundred at the Queen’s Park Oval.

    Quotes

    “We want to get accustomed to the conditions in Trinidad. We’ll make sure we do all the hard work and challenge West Indies, and see if we can win this Test series 2-0.”
    Mahela Jayawardene“I believe that if we can remain positive and focus, we can win the Test. It’s a must win situation for us to square the series. We’ll try and see what Sri Lanka has to offer a second time around both in the batting and bowling, so it is just for us to return to the drawing board, and come up with a plan, and come prepared to play a tough Test.”
    Chris Gayle

  • Mushtaq out for three weeks after knee surgery

    Sussex’s members looked quizzically at one another when Mushtaq Ahmed’s name was not mentioned in the team to face Surrey at Hove. It was later revealed that Mushtaq, Sussex’s whirling legspinner, underwent keyhole surgery on his right knee on Wednesday.”We made the decision very quickly on the Wednesday morning,” Mark Robinson, Sussex’s cricket manager, said. “We were originally hoping that we would just play him in four-day cricket up to the Twenty20 window where he’d then have the operation.”However, on reflection, we felt it wouldn’t be right to compromise our strike bowler by having him playing in discomfort, so, with the amount of unsettled weather around and the fact our club surgeon said he could get him in that day, we felt it was the wisest decision to make. It is a routine operation that many sportsmen have and we are hopeful that Mushy will be back between two and three weeks.”Mushtaq was replaced by Ollie Rayner, the young offspinner, as play finally got underway at Hove after the first day’s washout.

    Watson might need to give up bowling – Buchanan

    Shane Watson is a talented batsman but is constantly let down by his body © Getty Images

    Shane Watson should consider giving up bowling in a bid to resume his stalled Test career, according to his former coach John Buchanan. Watson missed Australia’s opening matches at the ICC World Twenty20 with a hamstring problem and again broke down with hamstring trouble in his first game.Sitting on the sidelines is not new to Watson. He missed the entire Ashes series with hamstring injuries, the start of the Word Cup with a calf strain and has also dealt with back and shoulder problems during his international career. Buchanan said he hoped Watson did not have to become a specialist batsman but it might be the only way to keep him on the field.”It’s an avenue he’s going to have to explore,” Buchanan told the . “You would hope it doesn’t come to that for him. Everyone is feeling for him. He’s a hard worker and does everything he can to get his body right. He’s an intense character and he’s only 26, so there are ten good years of cricket ahead of him.”Buchanan said Australia should consider using Watson as an opening batsman at Test level. Watson has expressed a strong interest in partnering Matthew Hayden at the top of the order but Phil Jaques and Chris Rogers are almost certainly ahead of him in the queue.”There’s no doubt he has the technical proficiency to open the batting at Test level,” Buchanan said. “He’s proved it in domestic cricket which, given the standard of our domestic competition, is a good barometer for Test cricket.”Opening the batting would necessarily reduce the amount of bowling, if any, he’d have to do in the Test side. From that point of view, it would be a plus and ease his workload. You couldn’t expect him to open the batting then bowl 20 overs in a day. But Shane is a talented bowler and I hope it’s a path he doesn’t have to take.”Buchanan said the regularity with which Watson would return from an injury only to break down again must erode his confidence. “He probably goes on the field hoping he’s going to get through it okay,” Buchanan said.”You don’t want to have those sort of thoughts at this level of sport. You have to have complete confidence in your fitness and your body. A big factor for him now will be how he deals with it all mentally.”

    Game
    Register
    Service
    Bonus